Integrated conjugative elements drive the formation of pandemic clones of Escherichia coli with hybrid chromosomes

Abstract Pathogenic multidrug-resistant bacteria with hybrid chromosomes have emerged as a significant global healthcare threat. These include the pandemic Escherichia coli ST1193, the product of homologous recombination events involving two phylogenetically distant strains of E. coli, in which mutant alleles of the widely-separated genes, gyrA and parC, generating high-level fluoroquinolone resistance were acquired. The mechanisms and frequency of hybrid formation are poorly understood. We developed a robust hybrid selection procedure and applied it to 118 clinical UTI isolates of E. coli mixed with suitable recipient strains. Hybrids were selected from 39% of isolates. All hybrids were recombinants of donor and recipient chromosomal DNA (median length of donor DNA 367 kb), with 90% also acquiring conjugative mobile genetic elements (MGE) from the donor. We showed that individual conjugative plasmids, and integrative conjugative elements (ICE), from donors were sufficient to drive hybrid formation. These observations strongly support conjugative chromosomal DNA transfer as the major mechanism underlying hybrid formation. ICE are genome-integrated and passively propagated but when transferring to recipients they normally do so by excising and producing their own conjugation machinery. We found that ICE were responsible for the highest frequencies of hybrid chromosome formation. They could mobilize DNA around the full length of the chromosome, including the simultaneous acquisition of mutant variants of gyrA and parC, separated by ∼826 kb, generating highly fluoroquinolone-resistant bacteria in a single event. Bacterial hybrid chromosome formation driven by conjugative MGE may be an important and widespread mechanism in the emergence and evolution of high-risk bacterial pathogens.