What question did this study set out to answer?

The study aims to develop a framework for detecting structural phase transitions in evaluative systems.

January 26, 2026Open Access

The Judge-Shift Diagnostic Framework: Detecting Structural Phase Transitions in Evaluative Systems

Key Points

The study aims to develop a framework for detecting structural phase transitions in evaluative systems.
Three-axis instrument measures internal reference rate, falsifiability score, and interpretation inconsistency.
Diagnosed transitions in specific historical contexts, including the Challenger disaster and a Biblical parable.
Analyzed the symmetry of trajectories at the phase-transition point.
Identified closing transition in the Challenger teleconference with a specific internal reference.
Revealed opening transition in Luke 18:9-14, highlighting a shift in reference.
Both transitions exhibited a critical signature of I = 1.00 at the phase transition point.

Abstract

The Judge-Shift Diagnostic Framework: Detecting Structural Phase Transitions in Evaluative Systems Overview This repository provides the manuscript and supplementary materials for a diagnostic framework that detects structural phase transitions in evaluative systems. Key Findings Three-axis instrument: Measures internal reference rate (pᵢnt), falsifiability score (F), and interpretation inconsistency (I) Bidirectional validation: Closing transition detected in the 1986 Challenger teleconference (external → internal reference) Opening transition detected in Luke 18: 9-14 (self → external reference) Shared critical signature: Both trajectories exhibit I = 1. 00 at the phase-transition point Sign-reversed symmetry: The trajectories are mirror images, suggesting a domain-general structure Contents File Description judgeₛhiftₘanuscriptᵥ2withₐuthor. pdf Main manuscript with author information figure1grayscale. png Figure 1: Challenger phase transition analysis figure2grayscale. png Figure 2: Symmetry comparison (Closing vs Opening) supplementaryₘaterials. md Appendix A–C: Prompt specifications, raw JSON outputs, reproducibility notes Scope Statement This work reports structural observations detected by a diagnostic instrument. It does not: Assert theological claims Predict outcomes Claim universal validity The symmetry observed is an empirical finding within the model, inviting interpretation across disciplines. Reproducibility Full prompt specifications (P1–P4) and raw JSON outputs are provided in the supplementary materials. The framework is designed for replication and external validation. Keywords phase transition · decision-making · organizational pathology · diagnostic framework · textual analysis · falsifiability Author Takayuki Takagi Independent Researcher, Higashimatsuyama, Saitama, Japan ORCID: 0009-0003-5188-2314 Email: lemissio@gmail. com License CC-BY 4. 0 Citation Takagi, T. (2025). The Judge-Shift Diagnostic Framework: Detecting Structural Phase Transitions in Evaluative Systems. Zenodo. https: //doi. org/10. 5281/zenodo. 18360948

Demander à l'IA

Bookmark

View Full Paper