Soil microbial communities can play a large role in plant fitness, including plants’ response to drought. How microbes mediate drought response may also differ across the plants’ life stage, but studies rarely study causal effects of microbes on plant fitness at multiple stages. We conducted a greenhouse experiment on switchgrass ( Panicum virgatum L.) to investigate how microbial presence (sterile bulk vs. live bulk soils) and microbial source (communities from bulk vs. rhizosphere soil) affect germination and seedling growth (life-stage) during drought. We also investigated how drought and life-stage alter the assembly of the inoculated communities. Both drought conditions and the absence of microbes reduced germination (49% and 50% fewer seedlings, respectively, p < 0.05), but there were few effects of microbial presence on older seedlings. In addition, microbial source had no effect on the evaluated plant traits, but interestingly, the initially similar bulk and rhizosphere communities became compositionally distinct after 34 days with germinating seeds, but not with seedlings. Therefore, it may be that the plants did respond to microbial source through changes in seed or root exudates, and calls for further study. Finally, while sometimes microbes did benefit plants under drought, we did not find evidence that they are especially beneficial in this condition. We suggest that microbes’ effects differ across plant life stage, and may be both positive and negative. Further research should advance understanding of plant stress tolerance within a framework of plant-microbiome co-development. • Microbial effects on plants vary by life-stage, and greater during germination • Soil microbial communities rarely buffered early-stage plant drought stress • Plant responses to rhizosphere and bulk soil taxa do not differ • Germinating seeds have distinct effects on microbial filtering and composition • We call for attention to soil sterilization artifacts in plant-microbial studies
Ulbrich et al. (Sun,) studied this question.