Anti-friction bearings are fundamental components of rotating machines. In bearing condition monitoring, fault detection is a primary task, as any undetected faults could result in catastrophic failures and downtime losses. To ensure effective and reliable fault detection, the use of appropriate sensors and measurement technologies is essential. This paper presents a comparative study on the applications of four sensor types in bearing condition monitoring. These four sensor types are vibration accelerometer, encoder, acoustic emission (AE) sensor and motor current probe. Their effectiveness and practicability in bearing fault detection are evaluted. Data simultaneously measured from these four sensor types on a split roller bearing within an experimental rig are used for the analysis. Different factors such as machine operating speeds, bearing fault sizes and their location are considered during the experiments to understand the effectiveness and fault detectability of different sensors on a common bearing. Both the accelerometer and the AE sensor are observed to effectively detect all bearing faults from small to extended sizes and from low to high operating speeds. However, the other two sensors, the encoder and motor current probe, have been found to be sensitive only to relatively larger fault sizes and higher operating speeds. The study presents valuable insights into their advantages and limitations through a systematic comparison of roller bearing fault detection. The study provides a basis for sensor selection in bearing condition monitoring and fault detection to enhance the reliability of industrial maintenance activities.
Wen et al. (Fri,) studied this question.