Systematic comparisons of how plants with contrasting ecological strategies respond to extremely wide nutrient availability gradients remain limited. We investigated the physiological, photosynthetic, and growth adaptations of four plant species representing distinct ecological strategies: Triticum aestivum L. (C3 annual crop), Zea mays L. (C4 annual crop), Ipomoea aquatica Forssk. (C3 annual/perennial aquatic vegetable), and Canna glauca L. (C3 perennial wetland ornamental). Plants were grown hydroponically under nitrogen (N), phosphorus (P), and potassium (K) gradients ranging from 0% to 500% of standard Hoagland nutrient solution. The study results showed that all measured plant traits exhibited characteristic unimodal dose–response patterns. Optimal performance mostly occurred at 100–150% nutrient availability gradients. Severe inhibition or mortality occurred at extreme gradients. Simultaneously, different plant species displayed markedly varying response amplitudes and nutrient-specific sensitivities. Z. mays showed the highest nutrient use efficiency and broadest optimal ranges, particularly for N and K. C. glauca exhibited extraordinary N responsiveness (32-fold increase in photosynthetic rate) but narrow optimal ranges (e.g., 1.01 ± 0.15 μmol CO2/(m2·s) at the 1% N treatment vs. 32.52 ± 3.33 μmol CO2/(m2·s) at the 150% N treatment). I. aquatica showed pronounced P limitation with broad tolerance to supra-optimal N and K. T. aestivum displayed moderate responses with clear sensitivity to N limitation. Root–shoot ratios declined systematically with increasing nutrient availability across all plant species, following negative exponential functions. The results of data analyses revealed significant effects of N, P, and K availability on all the determined plant traits. Correlation analyses demonstrated tight coupling effects among physiological, photosynthetic, and growth traits, indicating integrated whole-plant responses to nutrient variations. These findings reveal that plant ecological strategy systematically modulates nutrient response patterns and provide a quantitative framework for species-specific nutrient management. This study provides a theoretical basis for precision fertilization of aquatic vegetables and wetland plants, and more broadly support species-specific nutrient management in controlled-environment agriculture.
Fu et al. (Thu,) studied this question.