The Vehicle-to-Grid (V2G) technology is considered one of the best solutions for integrating renewable energy systems; however, most literature reports favorable economic results using synthetic data, without accounting for seasonal or market limitations. The current research presents the results of the MATLAB R2023b (Version 23. 2, MathWorks, Natick, MA, USA) simulation of the 100-household energy community in Debrecen, Hungary, with 30 electric vehicles (EVs) using entirely simulation-based Lithium Iron Phosphate (LiFePO4) batteries, a simulation-based 150 kW solar photovoltaic (PV) system, and a simulation-based 200 kW wind power system, using real meteorological data for January 2024. The optimization of charging/discharging for electric vehicles was performed using a multi-objective genetic algorithm (GA) over 30 days at a 15 min time resolution, accounting for stochastic loads and temperature effects on battery degradation, with a sensitivity analysis of key parameters. The results of the optimized solution for the electric vehicle charging/discharging were unexpected: the total energy cost increased by 68. 9% (4337. 65 to 7327. 54), the peak demand increased by 266. 2% (31. 9 to 116. 9 kW), the degradation cost was 479. 63, the load factor was reduced from 0. 847 to 0. 722, and the SOC constraint was violated for 0. 758% of measurements. The V2G is not economically viable under current Hungarian pricing and Central Europe winter conditions. Results are robust for varying parameters using sensitivity analysis and Pareto front tracing. The break-even point is achieved when ratios of peak-to-off-peak prices are above 3. 5: 1. Seasonal policies and market reforms are critical for V2G viability. Importantly, the influence of inherent design deficiencies in the optimization model on the reported results cannot be ruled out.
Khan et al. (Fri,) studied this question.