The specter of organized violence wars, conflicts, terrorism, authoritarian violence, genocides casts a long and devastating shadow across the globe, claiming hundreds of thousands of lives annually and trapping fragile nations in vicious cycles of economic decline and social decay (Introduction, pp. 1-2). In the face of such profound human cost, the imperative of conflict prevention is undeniable. Yet, as Bertrand Russell astutely observed, the challenge lies not in simple prescriptions but in the complex reality where each party controls only its own actions while attributing blame to the perceived “evil nature” of the other (Introduction, p. 2). This intricate landscape, far removed from the often-emotional portrayals in media and opinion scholarship, demands rigorous investigation grounded in hard evidence, robust theories and carefully considered concepts. It is precisely this critical need that the Research Handbook on Conflict Prevention, edited by Timo Kivimäki, endeavors to address.This comprehensive handbook, a testament to collective scholarly effort and integrative process (Introduction, p. 2), sets out to provide a thorough examination of conflict prevention by exploring three fundamental questions: who can prevent conflicts, how can they be prevented, and when might different methods be most effectively employed. The book is structured into three distinct parts, each delving into one of these core themes, building upon a foundational conceptual chapter by Kivimäki himself, “Conflict prevention: what does it really mean?” (Chapter 2). This initial chapter establishes the conceptual conventions of the handbook and lays the groundwork for the subsequent theoretical and empirical analyses.The author’s methodology, as evinced by the diverse contributions and the emphasis on interdisciplinary approaches, is a significant strength of this handbook. The book seamlessly integrates insights from various fields, including political science, international relations, sociology, gender studies, communication studies and law. For instance, the inclusion of chapters on “Women in conflict prevention” (Chapter 3, pp. 34-47) and “Hegemonic masculinity and the power-centric method of conflict prevention” (Chapter 11, pp. 180-197) demonstrates a crucial integration of feminist theory, challenging traditional, often gender-blind, analyses of conflict and security. Similarly, the application of game theory and bargaining theory in the analysis of peace negotiation (Chapter 8) and conflict onset prevention (Chapter 16, pp. 277-304) introduces a rigorous analytical framework from economics and political science. The inclusion of empirical studies based on quantitative data analysis (Chapter 5, pp. 64-85; Chapter 11, pp. 180-197; Chapter 17, pp. 305-323) alongside qualitative case studies (Chapter 6, pp. 86-102) and literature reviews (Chapter 7, pp. 104-121; Chapter 9, pp. 139-151) further enhances the book’s depth and breadth, offering a multimodal understanding of conflict prevention.One of the book’s significant strengths lies in its critical evaluation of established approaches and its willingness to challenge conventional wisdom. Chapter 5, “Whose conflict prevention works? Strong states vs the legitimate world organization” (pp. 64-85), stands out in this regard. Kivimäki’s empirical analysis comparing the impact of unilateral great power interventions and UN peacekeeping operations on organized violence yields surprising conclusions, suggesting that the UN, despite its perceived limitations, is significantly more effective in reducing fatalities. This finding directly challenges the often-held belief in the efficacy of unilateral force and highlights the importance of the UN’s representative legitimacy and principles of facilitating locally owned solutions.Another chapter that demonstrates particular novelty and originality is Chapter 11, “Hegemonic masculinity and the power-centric method of conflict prevention” (pp. 180-197). By applying feminist theory and discourse analysis to US presidential speeches, Kivimäki empirically demonstrates a correlation between power-centric rhetoric and the failure of conflict prevention. This chapter moves beyond theoretical critiques of masculine approaches to security and provides compelling evidence for the detrimental effects of such framings on conflict outcomes. The use of computer-assisted textual analysis to quantify power-centricity is a methodologically innovative approach within the field of conflict studies and offers a fresh perspective on the impact of language and discourse on international relations.Furthermore, Chapter 6, “Local vs international agency in conflict prevention” (pp. 86-102), offers a critical deconstruction of the often-simplistic binary between local and international approaches. Drawing on the case study of South Sudan, Pendle and Diing argue that these categories are often entangled and that the focus should shift from comparing their effectiveness to understanding how peacemakers at any level claim power and authority. Their emphasis on a “public authority” approach moves the debate beyond identity-based assumptions and toward a more critical examination of the dynamics of power in peacebuilding.While the handbook offers numerous strengths, a potential weakness lies in the inherent challenge of synthesizing such a diverse range of perspectives and methodologies within a single volume. While the introduction highlights the collaborative nature of the project and the efforts to avoid overlaps and gaps (Introduction, p. 2), the sheer breadth of topics covered can sometimes lead to a lack of in-depth exploration within individual chapters. For instance, while Chapter 12 on the International Criminal Court, economic sanctions, and the Responsibility to Protect (pp. 198-215) provides a valuable overview, a more detailed examination of the complex interplay and potential contradictions between these instruments in specific conflict contexts could have further enriched the analysis. Similarly, while Chapter 13 on military means (pp. 216-235) outlines the spectrum of military involvement, a more nuanced discussion of the unintended consequences and ethical dilemmas associated with military interventions, even for preventive purposes, might have been beneficial.Engaging with the author’s arguments and ideas, it becomes clear that the handbook collectively argues for a shift away from simplistic, one-size-fits-all approaches to conflict prevention toward a more nuanced, context-specific and multi-actor understanding. The emphasis on diverse agents, methods and timing underscores the complexity of the field and the need for tailored strategies. The critical evaluations of traditional power-centric approaches and the highlighting of alternative methodologies, such as feminist approaches and peace journalism, offer valuable original insights. The book implicitly argues that effective conflict prevention requires not only a deep understanding of the dynamics of violence but also a willingness to challenge ingrained assumptions and embrace innovative perspectives.The Research Handbook on Conflict Prevention fits squarely within a broader literature on peace and conflict studies, engaging with established debates while also pushing the boundaries of the field. It builds upon the foundational work of scholars like Edward Azar on protracted social conflict (Introduction, p. 1) and Bertrand Russell on the psychological dimensions of conflict (Introduction, p. 2). The discussions on negotiation and mediation (Chapters 7, 8, 9, pp. 104-151) engage with the extensive body of literature on conflict resolution and bargaining theory, while the chapters on conflict transformation (Chapters 10, 16, pp. 152-179, 277-304) connect with the evolution of peace research from focusing on conflict behavior to addressing underlying structures. The inclusion of chapters on gender and masculinity (Chapters 3, 11, pp. 34-47, 180-197) directly contributes to the growing field of feminist international relations and critical security studies. Furthermore, the discussions on the roles of international organizations and states (Chapters 5, 12, 13, pp. 64-85, 198-215, 216-235) are firmly rooted in the literature on international security and global governance. The handbook’s emphasis on timing and different stages of conflict (Part III, pp. 263-340) aligns with research on conflict dynamics and the sequencing of peace interventions. By bringing together these diverse strands of research, the handbook provides a comprehensive overview of the current state of knowledge while also identifying areas for future inquiry.The target audience for this book is broad and includes academics, researchers and students in the fields of peace and conflict studies, international relations, political science, sociology and related disciplines. The handbook’s rigorous analysis, empirical findings and theoretical frameworks make it an invaluable resource for those seeking to deepen their understanding of conflict prevention. Furthermore, the book through its questions of: who, how and when, is also highly relevant for practitioners working in international organizations, nongovernmental organizations, government agencies and other bodies involved in conflict prevention, peacebuilding and humanitarian work.Timo Kivimäki’s Research Handbook on Conflict Prevention offers a valuable resource for teaching a wide range of political science courses, from introductory classes on international relations and peace studies to advanced seminars on conflict resolution and security policy. Professors might use the book to introduce students to key debates about who can prevent conflict, how different actors states, international organizations, civil society can intervene, and when specific strategies are most effective. For beginning students, selected chapters can serve as the basis for role-playing exercises or simulations on peace negotiations, the role of gender in conflict, or the impact of international interventions. For more advanced students, the interdisciplinary chapters such as those applying game theory, discourse analysis or empirical case studies can form foundations for research projects, policy analysis or comparative studies of conflict prevention efforts. The book’s focus on diverse methodologies and real-world case studies makes it especially relevant for courses in international security, conflict studies and global governance, helping students critically evaluate different approaches and develop nuanced perspectives on conflict dynamics and prevention strategies. Overall, it is a versatile tool for fostering analytical skills and bridging theory with practice in political science education.In conclusion, the Research Handbook on Conflict Prevention, edited by Timo Kivimäki, is a groundbreaking and essential contribution to the field of peace and conflict studies. By introducing the complex landscape of organized violence and the imperative of its prevention, the handbook effectively sets the stage for a comprehensive exploration of the topic. The book’s main arguments, systematically presented across its three parts focusing on agents, methods and timing, provide a robust framework for understanding the multifaceted nature of conflict prevention.
Martial Agbor Fanga (Tue,) studied this question.