Loss of Ecosystem Resistance to Invasion after Wildfire Facilitated by a Pulse of Soil Nitrogen Availability: Experimental Evidence in the Burned Sagebrush Steppe

Abstract The impacts of climate shifts on ecosystems dominated by long-lived perennials are likely most pronounced during community reassembly after disturbances such as fire and confounded by interactions between disturbances and plant community composition. A 30-year-experimental hydroclimate manipulation of multiple sagebrush steppe communities was completely consumed by a 2019 wildfire, providing an opportunity to evaluate effects of precipitation deficit on ecosystem recovery. Ambient precipitation was doubled for 23 years via irrigation in winter or summer in grassland or shrub–steppe communities until 2016. Plots that had received irrigation thus experienced drought for three years preceding and continuing after the fire. These landscapes are vulnerable to invasion by exotic annuals such as Bromus tectorum L. (cheatgrass) that promote wildfire occurrence, which favors even greater invasion levels. Thus, we asked whether patterns of invasion after the compound disturbance of drought and fire related to the long-term pre-fire climate and plant community structure. Established theory led to the prediction that plant communities developed under wetter climates would have greater resistance to invasion. The most resistant plots were the most arid (that is, never irrigated control plots with no drought) which had the least pre-fire canopy cover of shrubs and nitrogen-fixing forbs and greater proportional cover of perennial bunchgrasses. Plots that developed under winter irrigation had greater cover of shrubs and N-fixing forbs, corresponding to pulses of plant available soil nitrogen that were 8.2-fold greater than pre-fire levels, compared to a 0.20-fold post-fire reduction in soil nitrogen observed in the ambient plots. Nitrogen pulses and invasion were most evident in the inter-canopy bare-soil patches (‘interspaces’) and were least evident where perennial grasses were most abundant. Long-term hydroclimate altered pre-fire plant community composition in ways that affected post-fire resistance to invasion such that the combined effects of fire and water deficit led to greater than expected invasion in wetter regions that are conventionally considered resistant to invasion and resilient to wildfire.