Recent work (Raufaste et al. 2022 Soft Matter, vol. 18, p. 4944) studied the dynamics of a soap film in the shape of an unstable minimal surface whose evolution is governed in part by the frictional forces associated with surface Plateau border (SPB) motion. In this note, we study a variant of this problem in which a half-catenoid bounded by a wire loop and a fluid bath axisymmetrically surrounds a cylindrical rod with a radius equal to the neck of the critical catenoid given by the wire loop. When the half-catenoid is brought just beyond the point of instability, the film touches the cylinder and separates from the bath, creating an SPB that is dragged upwards along the rod by the now unstable soap film, and asymptotically relaxes to a new stable annular minimal surface. For this free-boundary problem involving an unstable initial condition, we find the dynamics by balancing the capillary force of successive unstable minimal surfaces spanning the SPB and the wire loop with the frictional force associated with the moving SPB. We find good agreement between theory and experiment using the frictional force f Ca^2/3 given by Bretherton’s law, where Ca is the capillary number.
Polin et al. (2026) studied this question.