Authenticity, Fragilization, and Cross-Pressure in Charles Taylor’s A Secular Age

This paper critically examines Charles Taylor’s analysis in A Secular Age, with a focus on the concepts of authenticity, fragilization and cross-pressure. I explore the ethic of authenticity in relation to the ontological instability produced by exclusive humanism and consider how fragilization and cross-pressure reflect the fragmentation of our relation to the spiritual. At the same time, I engage with critical responses to Taylor that challenge his claims about authenticity and question the coherence and universality of fragilization and cross-pressure as social and cultural phenomena. I conclude that Taylor’s account of authenticity is fundamentally ambivalent, as it reproduces the rigid distinction between immanence and transcendence that the ethic of authenticity itself seeks ostensibly to destabilize.