This paper proposes a propensity score (PS)-based stratified win ratio method to address challenges of small patient populations in clinical trials, especially for rare or pediatric diseases, by incorporating external control data. Our approach enhances traditional win ratio analysis by leveraging PS stratification to account for heterogeneity between the current and external studies. Additionally, down-weighting based on the overlapping coefficient of PS distributions of current treatment and external control groups further mitigates the patient bias due to heterogeneity. Simulations show significant improvements in statistical power for detecting treatment effects within the composite endpoint combining continuous and time-to-event components, over nonborrowing and pooling methods, with utilizing Mantel-Haenszel (MH)-type weights achieving the highest power. The proposed methods are also applied to an amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS) study incorporating the external control arm from a prior ALS trial. The proposed PS-based stratified win ratio method thus provides a rigorous framework for borrowing external data and analyzing composite endpoints with limited patient availability.
Chen et al. (Sun,) studied this question.