Analysis of Detailed and Simplified Finite Element Modelling Strategies for Simulating the Failure Behaviour of Timber Frame Diaphragms

Timber frame diaphragms play a central role in the lateral stability of modern timber buildings, yet current design codes insufficiently capture their nonlinear behaviour and governing failure mechanisms. This study evaluates two finite element modelling strategies to improve the prediction of diaphragm response. The first strategy, implemented in MATLAB®, explicitly models the nonlinear behaviour of sheathing-to-framing (STF) connections using an oriented orthogonal multilinear damage law. Validation against experimental tests on partially anchored and fully anchored diaphragms as well as in-plane bending specimens demonstrated accurate predictions of stiffness and force–displacement behaviour in both the linear-elastic and elastoplastic ranges. Deviations in peak load predictions for the detailed model reached up to approximately 25%, while stiffness predictions remained within approximately 10% of the experimental values. The second approach, implemented in commercial structural engineering software, represents STF connections by uncoupled elastoplastic spring elements. Although post-peak softening cannot be captured, peak capacities were predicted within approximately 3–5% for several configurations, with reliable stiffness estimates in most cases. A quantitative comparison using the normalised root mean square error between experimental and numerical force-displacement curves yielded values between approximately 5% and 14%, indicating good agreement between the numerical predictions and the experimental behaviour. Overall, the detailed model enables high-fidelity nonlinear analysis and insight into failure mechanisms, whereas the simplified spring approach offers a practical and computationally efficient modelling strategy suitable for routine engineering design.