Hepatitis C virus and HIV transmission: parenteral (including percutaneous) routes are still relevant and must receive due attention

Hepatitis C virus (HCV) and HIV share parenteral (including percutaneous) routes of transmission.Even though these routes were considered in the past, attention, as far as HIV is concerned, has subsequently concentrated on sexual routes and vertical transmission.A case control study done in South Africa in 2016-2020 and recently published served as a reminder of the importance of percutaneous transmission. 1,163 men were screened for HIV 1/2, HBsAg and anti-HCV antibodies and administered a comprehensive questionnaire examining risk factors for potential HCV, HBV, and HIV infection (1). Seroprevalence for HIV was 17.2%, for HBV 6.9%, and for HCV 0.4%. HIV seropositivity was significantly more likely in those who regularly bled during clean-shave haircuts OR 2.51 (95% CI 1.16-5.42), p= 0.02, had a tattoo/piercing informally done OR 1.84, (95% CI 1.13-2.22), p= 0.01 or reported sexually transmitted genital lesions or discharge OR 1.58 (95% CI 1.13-2.22), p=0.01 (1). HIV/HCV co-infection was more likely in men with the same risk factors. Interestingly, HIV seroprevalence was elevated despite a high circumcision rate (91.2%) (1). In addition, in the state of Jharkhand, eastern India, five thalassemic children have seemingly been found HIV-positive in 2025 following transfusions received at a government hospital (2).A huge study done in another African country in 2019 is relevant to the issue of HCV and HIV transmission routes. In research involving 156,499 participants in Rwanda, 2.8% were found to be anti-HCV positive and 0.15% had HCV/HIV co-infection (3). History of surgical operation, scarification and exposure to traditional operational practices were associated with both infections, whereas a history of surgery or transfusion was associated with higher probability of HIV infection OR 1.42; (95% CI 1.21 to 1.66) and OR 1.48 (1.29 to 1.70), respectively; a history of physical traumatic assault was associated with a higher probability of HIV infection OR 1.69 (95% CI 1.51 to 1.88)(3).The above data highlights the importance of percutaneous, healthcare-related and transfusion-related transmissions (that contribute to the impact that HIV and HCV infections have on healthcare systems and to the associated costs)(4,5) and shows the need for population screening for blood borne viruses, particularly in countries where their burden is considerable.In a study done in 1997 in a rural Egyptian village, with a large sample size (almost 4,000 people) and a 1 in 4 prevalence of anti-HCV, circumcision by informal health care providers was associated with anti-HCV positivity (OR = 1.7, 1.0-3.0) and receiving injections from informal health care providers was associated with 20% higher odds of anti-HCV (p = 0.046)(64). A history of hospital admission was also associated with anti-HCV (p 10 vs. 0 therapeutic injections, adjusted OR=3.1, 95% CI: 1.2-7.9) and significantly more likely to have daily face (adjusted OR=5.1, 95% CI: 1.5-17.0) and armpit shaves (adjusted OR=2.9, 95% CI: 1.3-6.5) by a barber (86).Another Egyptian study published in 2004 showed that blood transfusions, invasive procedures (surgery and endoscopy), and shaving at community barbers were associated with anti-HCV positivity (97).In a Pakistani research published in 2008, 61.45% of HCV infections were likely due to multiple use of needles/syringes, 10.62% to major/minor surgery/dental procedures, 4.26% to blood transfusion and blood products, 3.90% to sharing razors during shaving or circumcision by barbers, piercing instruments, nail clippers, toothbrushes (108). A study in volunteer blood donors in the Northwest Frontier Province of Pakistan, published in the same year, showed that positive donors were more likely to have had 1-2 injections or >2 injections in the past year, or 1-5 intravenous drips or >5 i.v. drips in the past five years, and to have been shaved (facial and armpit) by barbers (119).In an investigation related to the consequences of the reuse of needles and syringes from 2008 to 2015 at a clinic in the Republic of Korea, a distinct HCV genotype 1a was found in 45 patients and in environmental specimens, showing a healthcare-associated outbreak caused by reuse of syringes and contaminated multi-dose vials (120). In Taiwan, a nosocomial HCV outbreak occurred in May-July 2017 in a 30-bed respiratory care ward, where four ventilator-dependent patients acquired HCV infection, and their HCV-RNA sequences were highly similar to those of a patient in the same ward with chronic hepatitis C. The cases had received many more injections than the patients who had remained uninfected; infection control assessment revealed inadequate disinfection of equipment and environment (131). Patient-to-patient transmission most likely was a consequence of contamination during the preparation and administration of injections (131).In Italy, data from the national surveillance system for acute viral hepatitis for the period 2000-2021 were used to investigate the association between potential risk factors and the risk of acute HBV and HCV infections. Importantly, healthcare-associated transmission of hepatitis C virus continues to occur in community and hospital settings not only in low-and middle-income but also in high-income countries (such as those in European Union and European Economic Area, and the United Kingdom) (186).In Kumalo and colleagues' study, circumcised men were apparently more likely to have HIV in univariate analysis OR 2.02 (95% CI 1.03-3.94), p= 0.04, or HIV/HCV OR 2.04 (1.04-4.00), p=0.04 (1). In multivariate analysis, the ORs were 1.68 (0.84-3.37; p=0.14), and 1.69 (0.84-3.39; p=0.14), respectively, so the results were not statistically significant (1). Traditional circumcision was done in 950/1,055 (90.05%) cases and medical circumcision in 105/1,055 (9.95%) (1).It may be that traditional circumcision was done in late adolescence in settings without proper sterilization (197), and that HIV was acquired in that circumstance; however, if that were the case, it is surprising that AIDS had not manifested by the time these people were tested (median age 33.4 years, IQR 27.8-42.0).It may also be that those circumcised men in this study, believing that they were protected against HIV, have had unprotected sex more frequently or with more partners. In fact, in some communities, traditionally circumcised men have multiple sexual intercourses without using condoms and believe that circumcision completely protect them from HIV acquisition (2018).Anyway, circumcision did not influence HIV acquisition later in life in the study population (1). The authors stated that the lack of a positive effect of circumcision "does suggest that other factors override its potential value in HIV prevention in this group" (1). Indeed, their surprising results point to a greater importance of non-sexual HIV transmission routes in respect of sexual transmission.A case-control study was conducted from September through December 2018 in recently identified anti-HIV positive individuals and in seronegative subjects in the district of Unnao, Uttar Pradesh, India (2119). In multivariate logistic regression, unsafe injection exposure with already used needles (OR 6.61, 95% CI 1.80-24.18) and receipt of intramuscular injection in the preceding five years (OR 7.20, 95% CI 1.48-34.88) were independently associated with anti-HIV positivity, and the monophyletic clustering of HIV sequences from 14 cases indicated a common ancestry (2119). Anti-HCV antibodies were present in high proportion among study participants, especially in those with HIV infection (2119).In Roka, Battambang province, Cambodia, an HIV outbreak involving 242 individuals in 2014-2015 was linked to injections received from an unlicensed health practitioner; 78% of the people infected with HIV were found to be HCV co-infected (220).At a hospital-based pediatric antiretroviral clinic in Cape Town, South Africa, children with suspected horizontally acquired HIV infection were found through retrospective folder review of 2004-2014 patients and prospective interview and examination of patients from 2009 onwards (231). 32 children acquired HIV, with transmission considered healthcare-associated in 15 (46.9%), community-associated in 10 (31.3%), possibly healthcare or community-associated in five (15.6 %); and unknown in two (6.3%)(231). Numerous studies, summarized by David Gisselquist (242) and done previously in other (including sub-Saharan African) countries, demonstrated an even more important role for healthcare-associated HIV infections in children.In 2019, an HIV outbreak occurred in Larkana District, Sindh, Pakistan. By December of that year, 881 ( Unfortunately, over five years later, undiagnosed HIV infections persist in the community in Larkana, being common among children in Ratodero, where the outbreak was first noticed, and among both adults and children in surrounding areas (264). Exposure to unsafe injections (60%), unsafe blood transfusion (10%) and dental or surgical procedures (5%) are the most common modes of transmission ( 264).An HIV cluster occurred in 2018-2023 among former spa clients of an unlicensed spa providing cosmetic injection services in New Mexico, USA, and was associated with receipt of platelet-rich plasma microneedling facials (275).It has long been well known how to prevent bloodborne infections (28). Sterility of needles and other equipment used in medical settings (including by dentists and in hemodialysis centers) and in rituals must be constantly controlled. Availability of auto-disabled syringes and needles, routine compliance with infection control precautions and efficient sterilization of medical instruments, including endoscopes, appropriate community information and enforcement of regulatory practices are extremely important. All blood donations must be adequately screened. Unnecessary medical injections, unnecessary transfusions, reuse of needles and syringes must be banned. Policies must be developed to enforce the use of sterilized equipment for scarifications and tattooing. Screening and eventual treatment of people in prison and of intravenous drug users should be implemented as well as infection control training programs and surveillance systems for nosocomial infections.It is essential to reduce parenteral transmission of HIV and HCV. Sterility of needles and other equipment used in medical settings and in rituals must be constantly controlled. Availability of autodisabled syringes and needles, compliance with infection control precautions and efficient sterilization of medical instruments, including endoscopes, appropriate community information and enforcement of regulatory practices are extremely important.A targeted approach using combined testing for bloodborne viral infections could facilitate an early diagnosis in the general population. Unfortunately, a recent, comprehensive systematic review and meta-analysis examining the diagnostic performance of published predictive models for these infections in a wide range of populations and settings identified very large variations and a high risk of bias (296). Hence, efforts must be made to develop and evaluate more valid models.In healthcare settings, it must be remembered that guidelines alone are insufficient for infection prevention in the absence of sufficient staffing. Healthcare workers are generally aware of guidelines for injection practices to prevent infection; however, they do not consistently follow them, due to high workload because of understaffing, or difficulty to applyapplying consistently aseptic technique (3027). Higher workload among workers in larger hospitals can indeed lead to reduced compliance with guidelines in respect of medium-sized hospitals (3027).Finally, hospital-acquired infection underreporting must be reduced, developing a non-punitive reporting culture and favoring accurate, transparent, and constructive reporting (3128).