Earthworms, Soil Porosity, and Infiltration Rates in Pine Plantation Forests in Java, Indonesia

Pine plantations on volcanic slopes in Indonesia are considered to be forests and are managed for wood production and slope protection. Logging practices followed by replanting may affect soil health. Existing agroforestry management contracts allow farmers to intercrop with vegetables in young plantations and grow fodder grasses in older ones. However, critical data on hydrological functions in such systems are scarce, while concerns over heavy rainfall and floods increase. We explored the relationships between soil cover, soil carbon, earthworms, soil porosity and infiltration rates in relation to slope class in second-rotation pine plantations around two years of age (intercropped) and at ten-year old pine-grass stages. Five slope classes (0%–8%, 8%–15%, 15%–25%, 25%–45%, and >45%) were compared with three measurement points each. Basic soil chemical and physical characteristics were measured for the 0–10, 10–20 and 20–30 cm layers. Remnant natural forest was available as a historical reference only on the steepest slope class. Organic soil carbon (COrg) divided by a texture-based reference level was 1.12, 0.32 and 0.49 for natural forest, young and old agroforestry on very steep slopes, respectively. Within pine-based agroforestry relative decline with slope class (1–5) was pronounced in earthworms (biomass −3.46, population −4.18) and infiltration rates (−2.35) while bulk density increased (0.49); for soil carbon (COrg), nitrogen, available phosphorus and exchangeable Mg effects in the −1.26 to −1.68 range indicated a loss of functional topsoil. Differences with age of the agroforestry systems were much smaller but included a decreasing earthworm population but an increase in mean earthworm weight and partial recovery of the COrg/CRef ratio. Pine-based agroforestry on very steep soils had only 10%–14% of the earthworm biomass and 35% of the infiltration rate of reference natural forest. Understory vegetation biomass and litter layer necromass were more than five-fold higher in the natural forest. Across all samples a higher COrg and higher earthworm biomass were associated with complementary positive changes in infiltration rates and soil porosity. Regression analysis suggests equal skill of tree cover, soil COrg, porosity, aggregate stability and earthworms to predict infiltration rates while explanatory variables were strongly correlated. Management of the pine plantations may have to achieve a closer approximation of the conditions in natural forests to effectively protect upper watersheds.