We prove that no map satisfying three operationally motivated requirements---definiteness (observation produces a classical record), record stability (observation cannot render a classical record indefinite), and linearity (the map acts linearly on the operator algebra)---can consistently observe the complete state of the system containing it. The proof is short; the contribution is layered. First, the assumption set is strictly weaker than the projection postulate and the Lüders rule, so the result subsumes Breuer's 1995 self-measurement no-go from a smaller axiomatic base. Second, and more importantly, the conclusion is constructive: where Breuer establishes an epistemic limitation on internal state-assignment, we establish an ontological requirement on the location of definite-outcome-producing capacity. A composite-closure lemma extends the result up the observer hierarchy and forbids mutual-observation fixed points, converting the diagnostic disjunction of Frauchiger and Renner (2018) into a directed conclusion: consistent observation of a complete quantum system requires an observer external to that system, and no finite arrangement of mutual observers closes the recursion.
Building similarity graph...
Analyzing shared references across papers
Loading...
Dovid Gurevich
Building similarity graph...
Analyzing shared references across papers
Loading...
Dovid Gurevich (Fri,) studied this question.
www.synapsesocial.com/papers/6a0021fec8f74e3340f9cfef — DOI: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.20090379