Tensile, Edgewise Bending, Flatwise Bending, and Non-Destructive Evaluations of Visually Graded Fir Boards

Tensile, edgewise, and flatwise bending behaviors of visually graded fir (Abies nordmanniana subsp. bornmuelleriana) boards were investigated through destructive and non-destructive testing to evaluate their mechanical performance and grading accuracy. A total of 724 specimens were prepared and tested in accordance with EN 408 standards. Knot diameter ratios (narrow, mean, and parallel) were used to establish three visual grading methods. Vibration-based (PLG, Hitman) and time of flight (ToF) (Microsecond Timer, Ultrasonic Timer, and Sylvatest Duo) techniques were used for non-destructive evaluation (NDE), along with screw withdrawal tests. The results showed that although the vibration method had lower dynamic modulus of elasticity (MOEd) values ​​than the ToF method, it provided stronger correlations with tensile and bending properties. The mean and parallel knot diameter ratios provided more reliable grading results than the narrow ratio. Tensile strength was more affected by defects than bending strength, and the flatwise bending method consistently produced the highest strength values. The adjustment from global to local MOE reduced modulus values below 9000 MPa, resulting in lower strength class assignments. Overall, the vibration-based NDE method proved the most effective for predicting lumber quality, and the flatwise bending test emerged as a viable alternative to tension and edge bending methods for structural grading.