Key Performance Indicators in Building Renovation: A Detailed Systematic Literature Review

The main objective of this study is to produce a systematic literature review that analyses key performance indicators (KPI) in the context of efficient and sustainable building renovation. Efficiency and sustainability, in combination with building renovation, are important themes due to the increasing need for creating sustainable renovations worldwide. The identification and monitoring of KPIs is fundamental in decision-making processes, but also in the monitoring of short-term and long-term project goals. In the current academic literature, existing research gaps, especially in the social aspects of sustainability and research, have also been analyzed in terms of regional differences in the approach to each KPI. The systematic literature review examined 29 studies published between 2014 and 2024, based on a literature search conducted in 2024, using databases such as Scopus and Web of Science, with the final search performed in June 2024. The inclusion criteria focused on peer-reviewed studies addressing KPIs in sustainable building renovation, while studies not directly related to renovation processes or lacking KPI analysis were excluded. The research results show that the majority of studies focus on economic and environmental factors, which are the most commonly addressed, while research on other KPIs is significantly behind. The results were synthesized using a qualitative comparative analysis of identified KPI categories. This study also highlights the importance of addressing effective and sustainable renovation for historic buildings with a focus on heritage preservation and the need to further analyze the use of KPIs with a focus on historic buildings. The limitations include the limited number of studies and the underrepresentation of social sustainability aspects.