Influence of Turbulence Modeling on CFD-Based Prediction of Vehicle Hydroplaning Speed

Most computational studies of vehicle hydroplaning have emphasized structural realism through fluid–structure interaction, tire deformation, tread geometry, and pavement surface characterization. By contrast, the hydrodynamics governing the flow in the tire vicinity, particularly the role of turbulence, have received comparatively limited attention. In a significant number of studies, the flow has been treated as laminar despite turbulent flow conditions, while in a few other studies turbulence modeling has been adopted without an explicit assessment of its impact on hydroplaning predictions. In this study, we present a simplified three-dimensional computational fluid dynamics (CFD) model designed to isolate the flow regimes governing hydroplaning and to quantify the mean effect of the turbulence modeling on the predicted hydroplaning speed. Using a finite-volume formulation with a volume-of-fluid representation of the air–water interface, the flow around and beneath a smooth 0.7 m-diameter tire sliding in locked-wheel mode over a flooded, nominally smooth pavement is simulated. The tire is represented as a rigid body with an idealized rectangular bottom patch whose area is determined from the tire load and inflation pressure, avoiding the need to prescribe a measured or assumed deformed footprint. Steady-state hydroplaning is modeled for a uniform upstream water film thickness of 7.62 mm with a 0.5 mm gap between the tire and the pavement, over tire inflation pressures ranging from approximately 100 to 300 kPa, and predictions are verified against the empirical NASA hydroplaning equation. For these conditions, simulations without turbulence closure exhibit a consistent, systematic underprediction of the hydroplaning speed of approximately 13.5% relative to the NASA relation. Incorporating turbulence effects through Reynolds-averaged closures substantially reduces this bias, with average deviations of about 6% for the realizable k–ε model and 2.4% for the shear stress transport (SST) k–ω model. An analysis of the results indicates that hydrodynamic lift is dominated by pressure buildup associated with stagnation at the lower leading edge of the tire, with a significant contribution from shear-dominated flow in the thin under-tire gap, and that turbulence acts to moderate the integrated lift from these pressure fields. These results demonstrate that explicitly accounting for turbulence in the tire vicinity is essential for reproducing empirical hydroplaning trends and for avoiding systematic bias in CFD-based hydroplaning predictions.