From Phenotypes to Spectrum: Rethinking RRMS, SPMS and PPMS in the Era of PIRA—A Framework Integrating PIRA, Smouldering-Associated Worsening, and Neurologic Reserve to Facilitate Earlier Recognition of Progression

The conventional classification of multiple sclerosis (MS) into relapsing–remitting, secondary progressive, and primary progressive phenotypes has long guided diagnosis, prognosis, and therapeutic decision-making. However, accumulating evidence indicates that disability accumulation frequently occurs independently of clinical relapses, challenging relapse-centric and phenotype-based models of disease evolution. The concept of progression independent of relapse activity (PIRA) has emerged as a clinically relevant framework capturing this phenomenon across MS phenotypes. In this state-of-the-art narrative review, we propose a spectrum-based reinterpretation of MS, integrating PIRA with concepts of smouldering-associated worsening and neurologic reserve. We highlight the heterogeneity of relapse-independent worsening, distinguishing transient from persistent PIRA, and discuss how ageing-related decline in compensatory capacity contributes to the clinical unmasking of progression over time. Within this framework, secondary progressive MS is redefined as the clinically recognizable accumulation of persistent relapse-independent worsening, while primary progressive MS is conceptualized as early predominance of clinically manifest progression due to limited reserve rather than a distinct disease entity. Finally, we examine diagnostic and therapeutic implications of a spectrum-based model in the contemporary era, emphasizing the limitations of relapse-centric treatment strategies and unmet needs in addressing progression-related biology. By reframing MS as a dynamic continuum shaped by the interaction between ongoing pathology and evolving neurologic reserve, this review aims to support earlier recognition of clinically meaningful progression and to inform more biology-aware approaches to disease monitoring and therapy.